If you’re looking to move to New York City, two boroughs likely at the top of your list are Brooklyn and Manhattan. Both offer distinct neighborhoods, vibrant communities, endless entertainment options and convenient public transit access. However, significant lifestyle differences exist between these two iconic NYC boroughs.
Choosing whether Brooklyn or Manhattan best matches your needs and preferences ultimately comes down to personal priorities around housing budgets, commute times, proximity to attractions, nightlife preferences and whether you favor dense urban living or more residential neighborhoods. This guide examines key factors to weigh.
What is Your Preferred Lifestyle?
Manhattan living reflects the quintessential fast-paced, cosmopolitan experience depicted in movies and television. As an island borough, its dense geography constrains housing supply, making personal space at a premium. With 1.6 million residents crammed into soaring high-rise neighborhoods, one smells food carts wafting through the air as residents hustle along crowd sidewalk under bright billboard lights and store neon signs. For better or worse, Manhattan feels more hectic but conveniently walkable if you appreciate round-the-clock urban energy.
Brooklyn offers a more relaxed vibe while retaining NYC vibrancy across historic districts filled with tree-lined streets of brownstones to newly built rental towers near the East River waterfront. Space feels less congested, especially further out from central downtown districts. Pedestrian traffic and street noise rarely reaches Manhattan levels except in the heart of areas like Williamsburg or Downtown Brooklyn.
What Kind of Building Do You Want to Live In?
Due to Manhattan’s strictly limited space, apartments predominantly exist in high-rise or converted pre-war buildings. While luxury towers boast full amenity packages, older tenement-style walk up buildings still abound across many areas like the Lower East Side. Depending on your preferences, these older buildings provide historic architectural charm but generally feature smaller, at times quirky floorplans compared to modern units.
Brooklyn strikes a blend – plenty of gleaming new rental towers exist but you also find aesthetically pleasing limestone and brownstone blocks with older converted houses segmented into rentals. Several Brooklyn neighborhoods like Park Slope and Bed-Stuy are known for tree-lined streets showcasing intricate Victorian home architecture. More options for renters preferring historic buildings exist in Brooklyn than space-strapped Manhattan.
What Are Your Commuting and Public Transit Needs?
Manhattan resides at the center of New York City’s enormous public transportation network. Dozens of subway and bus lines crisscross the borough, including major trunk routes like the 2/3, A/C/E and 7 lines. Walking also proves feasible for many commutes and activities given the borough’s density and walkability.
While Brooklyn also offers plenty of subway access, trains generally run less frequently than busy Manhattan routes, especially further out from downtown. More reliance on buses and longer multi-seat commutes often prove necessary in Brooklyn compared to Manhattan. If easy access to Midtown offices or reducing transit time rank among your highest priorities, Manhattan prevails.
How Much Does It Cost To Live In Each Borough?
Rental prices and housing square footage still skew substantially higher in Manhattan versus Brooklyn. People easily pay 30-40%+ more in rent to lease comparable-sized apartments in most Manhattan neighborhoods compared to trendy Brooklyn locales.
However, significant price diversity exists within each borough based on neighborhood desirability, building age, proximity to attractions and other hyperlocal factors. Several still somewhat affordable pockets exist across Upper Manhattan neighborhoods like Washington Heights, Inwood and Harlem compared to the astronomical rents in central park areas below 96th Street, where homes range from gleaming modern luxury towers to 19th century historic brownstones with intricate stone facades and old factory loft buildings with large warehouse window providing eclectic vibes.
Likewise in Brooklyn, modern luxury buildings in Williamsburg or newly built Downtown towers near the Barclays Center run huge rents while areas further out from the city core like Sheepshead Bay, Flatlands and Midwood remain relatively affordable bastions for price-conscious residents. Painting with too broad of a brush obscures this hyperlocal diversity. Not all areas of Manhattan or Brooklyn strictly reflect prevailing stereotypes about pricing.
Most and Least Expensive Neighborhoods
While exceptions exist depending on housing stock, these borough neighborhoods currently reflect the greatest premiums for rental housing as of 2023. Budget accordingly here or expect severe sticker shock:
Most Expensive Manhattan Neighborhoods
- SoHo ($5,000+ average rent for 1BR)
- NoHo ($4,500+ for 1BR)
- TriBeCa ($4,500+)
- Greenwich Village ($4,000+)
- Flatiron District ($3,800+)
Most Expensive Brooklyn Neighborhoods
- DUMBO ($3,800+ for 1BR)
- Brooklyn Heights ($3,300+)
- Williamsburg ($3,200+)
- Park Slope ($2,800+)
- Fort Greene ($2,700+)
Conversely, these areas currently offer relatively more rental affordability. Compromising on commute times or proximity to downtown unlocks significant savings:
Most Affordable Manhattan Areas
- Inwood ($2,100 average 1BR rent)
- Harlem ($2,400)
- Hamilton Heights ($2,200)
- Washington Heights ($2,300)
- Chinatown ($2,500)
Most Affordable Brooklyn Neighborhoods
- Bensonhurst ($1,900 average for 1BR)
- Brighton Beach ($2,000)
- Sunset Park ($2,000)
- Sheepshead Bay ($1,950)
- Brownsville ($1,700)
Where to Find Nightlife and Entertainment
Hands down, Manhattan outpaces the outer boroughs when it comes to sheer concentration of renowned museums like the MoMA and Guggenheim, Broadway theater performances, Michelin-star restaurants led by celebrity chefs and bustling nightclubs spanning Chelsea, Hell’s Kitchen and the East Village fills with NYU students. Years worth of culture, dining, and after-dark options pack into this 23-square mile borough.
However, Brooklyn still offers plenty for residents craving entertainment. The borough provides top-tier art spaces like the Brooklyn Museum, indie theaters scattered throughout Williamsburg, and a thriving foodie scene with hip new eateries opening constantly. Nightlife hotspots range from EDM clubs along the East River waterfront to quirky dive bars packed with hipsters in Bushwick. Yet Brooklyn generally feels more residential once you venture off the main commercial drags – especially outer borough areas distant from downtown.
Where to Find Major Attractions and Events
From massive cultural draws like Broadway theaters in the Theater District to Times Square’s neon-lit extravaganzas view by millions of annual tourist, Rockefeller Center’s iconic ice skating rink and Radio City Music Hall to annual events like the Thanksgiving Day Parade and New Year’s Eve ball drop watched by billions before the bright lights of the Empire State Building, Manhattan unquestionably brims with numerous world-famous attractions you won’t find elsewhere in NYC.
Brooklyn’s top attractions like Coney Island’s beachfront boardwalk and Luna Park, the Brooklyn Botanic Gardens, views from the Brooklyn Heights Promenade facing Lower Manhattan’s skyline and Prospect Park simply don’t match Manhattan’s intense concentration of instantly recognizable sites.
The Costs of Living – Taxes, Utilities, Transportation
Both boroughs face city income taxes, expensive utility costs and Metrocard-dependent public transit expenses like any areas of NYC. However, minute differences exist:
Taxes: Manhattan residents face slightly higher income tax rates given additional district assessments. Budget for a ~0.5% difference.
Utilities: Brooklyn residents may pay marginally cheaper electricity supply rates depending on provider. Opting for energy efficient lifestyles cuts costs regardless of borough.
Public Transit: Subways run 24/7 in Manhattan with multiple express lines while Brooklyn relies more on buses/subways with fewer night owls. More varied transit options exist in Manhattan.
Groceries/Essentials: Food costs are generally consistent citywide though produce delivery logistics may differ slightly. Manhattan offers corner bodegas practically everywhere given extreme density.
Parking & Ownership Costs: Owning a car proves vastly more expensive in Manhattan given parking scarcity and rental rates averaging $500-600+ per month. Traffic also moves slower on average.
Private/Public School Options: Manhattan and Brooklyn both offer a range of elementary -> high school options. Perform thorough research on quality, ratings and costs well in advance before committing to neighborhoods if schools prove important,
Which NYC Borough Suits You Better? – A Quick Comparison
| Manhattan | Brooklyn | |
|---|---|---|
| Housing Supply | Heavily constrained. Mostly high-rise/converted buildings | Mix of high-rise + neighborhood rows of historic brownstones |
| Neighborhood Diversity | Hyper-localized district diversity in small footprint | Wider spectrum of neighborhoods overall |
| Cost Of Living | Astronomical. Highest rents + living costs in NYC | Ranges from very expensive to still somewhat affordable further out |
| Commuting & Public Transit | Extensive 24/7 subway & bus routes for easy mobility | Good coverage near downtown but thinner outer reaches relying more on buses |
| Crowds & Tourists | Teeming year-round, especially in Midtown/Downtown | Far fewer visitors aside from small pockets like DUMBO/Williamsburg |
| Walkability To Attractions | Very walkable given extreme density of attractions/culture/dining | Most destinations require some subway trips aside from micro-neighborhood offerings |
| Nightlife & Entertainment Density | Unparalleled at macro-scale. Endless top-tier offerings citywide | Robust but clustered in areas like Williamsburg/Downtown. More residential by outer neighborhoods |
| Major World-Famous Attractions | Too many to list. Global icons like Broadway, Times Square and more | Not near Manhattan levels though still great local options |
Quick Summary
Whether optimal home base lies in gritty yet vibrant Manhattan lofts or laid-back Brooklyn brownstones comes down to balancing housing budgets, proximity to workplaces, preferences on density of attractions/offerings, and many personal factors.
Think deeply about lifestyle priorities today and growth plans for the future before committing. Tour specific neighborhoods at varied times firsthand pre-move to determine comfort levels as well. Choosing the borough and communities best fitting your needs takes legwork but prevents restlessness later.
The magic of New York City shines bright across both these iconic boroughs, just in uniquely different ways. Choose wisely what resonates then embrace all the dynamic culture around you!
Seeking the Ideal NYC Room?
Imagine not just an ordinary room, but a lively community waiting to be called ‘home’. SharedEasy Coliving welcomes you to a new way of living! Discover our stylish, fully-equipped rooms, designed to complement your dynamic New York life.
Make Your Move Now:
Tap “Get Offer” or dial +1 929-575-4767 to explore how SharedEasy can elevate your living experience. Enjoy the convenience of flexible leases, inclusive amenities, and rooms prepped for immediate move-in. Your vibrant NYC community is calling. Become part of the SharedEasy family today!
